Just Released: Community Impact Report '24-'26

Rosh Hashanah 5787 Sermons

erev rosh hashanah

Let’s revisit these days of awe.

Erev Rosh Hashanah – by Rabbi Lauren and Rabbi Evon

L: Shanah Tovah!

E: Shanah Tovah U’Mitukah!

L: We are just so blessed….

E: Blessed to be here, to be in this Gem of Creation…

L: With all of you, continuing to weave our web of Jewish Community, our Tahoe Jewish Community, our congregations, our visitors… our ecosystem of Jewish Joy…our Mountain Judaism.

E: Rabbi? Did you say weave our web?

L: Yes…

E: Makes me think of Spider Man and the new sensation this summer… webs…. All make me think about super powers… Rabbi…what would be your super power.

L: Oh, I would definitely want teleportation. Get to travel anywhere!

E: I mean, that is pretty great, but is there anywhere else you would like to be right now?

L: Not really. This is pretty perfect. Especially for Rosh HaShanah and the start of our New Year. So, what would you choose for your super power?

E: Oh! Time travel! Getting to meet great historic personalities and moments, and maybe even fix mistakes.

L: I mean, that’s pretty great. But there is a certain power of being in the now. There is something to be said about the radical presence of this moment.

E: For sure, being present is something I work so hard at and strive for…I do not always get there, but strive for, so what other power would you have?

L: Well, what about super speed? I would be able to get so much more done!

E: Yeah, but what would you miss along the way? I learned in my first Wilderness First Responder course an important motto: Go slow to go fast. When in a moment of responding, we often rush, but often it leads to better outcomes when we slow down, just a bit, to gather more information, to notice what’s really going on, and then act….

L: I see some of that Shabbat wisdom sneaking in… and, if that’s how you are feeling… and if we’re focusing on super powers, what about the super power of awareness?

E: Is that really a super power like super speed, or teleportation or time travel? Don’t we all have awareness, knowing things are happening around us and that existence, well, exists…

L: But the super power of awareness lets you be present with your own thoughts, break bad habits, and change your life instead of running on autopilot. There is a phrase I have come to love for this: radical presence. Radical presence is more than mindfulness or awareness. It is the choice to be so fully here—in this moment, in this place, with these people—that we become available to the web of connections that the moment is asking of us.
E: I agree so much…. So [pause, aha moment] radical presence is contemplative. It means actually seeing the mountains instead of driving past or sitting among them; actually tasting the meal instead of eating on the run; actually hearing the shofar instead of already thinking about what comes next.
L: Radical presence is also relational. It means noticing the person standing beside us. It means noticing the world around us, even if it’s just the beauty of a small plant or bush. It means seeing the need for connection between us. The stranger who has wandered into our community and does not yet know where to sit. The friend whose joy deserves to be celebrated. The neighbor who needs someone to show up.
E: Awareness is the superpower.
L: Radical presence is what happens when we decide to use it.
E: The potential for growing our awareness is within each….and all of us…

L: This is why we are here today. This is one of the callings of Rosh HaShanah and its ancient wisdom. A call to awareness, a call to be radically present with ourselves and one another.

E: It’s the power of Hineini. Which means: Hineh Ani…. Here… I am… It is an expression from our tradition illustrating this kind of being….being present, being aware, and even sometimes being ready for what we are called to engage with…

L: It’s the moment as God calls to Abraham and Abraham responds: Hineini, here I am.

E: It’s the moment as God calls to Moses

L: Or Samuel

E: Or Isaiah

L: And so many of our sacred stories that we read on these holy days, each in its own way, calls us to embrace this super power. Or really any moment in which our prophets and our people–both ancient and modern–say to one another, “Hineini, here I am.” It’s a “Hineini Moment”. Or even better, it’s striving for not just moments, but a Hineini State of Mind.

E: The power of awareness…the behavior of radical presence… This Hineini state of mind pervades our tradition and certainly this season of the Yamim Noraim – the Days of Awe. It is told that a student once came to Rabbi Bunim, a Polish Hasidic master. The disciple was yearning for a practice to achieve greater spiritual awareness. Rabbi Bunim turned his gaze to the grandfather clock ticking on the wall. He asked the student, “What does the clock say?” Puzzled, the student responded with confusion, a mix of statement and question, “It just ticks?” Rabbi Bunim shook his head and explained: Every tick of the clock is a herald crying out: ‘A moment of your life has passed, and it will never return.’ The clock is telling you to wake up and be entirely here, for this moment is vanishing.

The Hasidim taught about pizour hanefesh – the scattering of the soul…it is a recognition that often we get snared by past regrets and future anxieties. The ticking clock serves as a radical alarm to draw our wandering minds to the immediate, to the moment – our now. Whether a clock ticking or the blasts of the shofar, now is the time to embrace our super power of awareness…and allow ourselves to be radically present.

L: In 1893, a young Jewish nurse named Lillian Wald was teaching home nursing on New York’s Lower East Side when a child led her to a tenement where the child’s mother was desperately ill. Wald later referred to this visit as a moment of awareness and radical presence; it was a turning point in her life just as prophetic as Abraham with the angel or Moses with the Burning Bush, or Samuel in the borderlands between dreaming and awareness. The child and mother cried out and Lillian responded with radical presence. She allowed this encounter to redirect her life: she moved into the neighborhood, and founded what became the Henry Street Settlement and the Visiting Nurse Service.

This openness of heart, the ability for her to be in that Hineini State of Mind, empowered Lilian to collaborate with a whole yet aching community. Wald could have treated one patient and returned to her previous life. Instead, she allowed herself to see what that one encounter revealed.

She paused and followed.
Her curiosity enabled her to notice both one woman suffering and the system surrounding her.
And Lillian responded by building a community of care.

E: Both of these deeply human tales identify the super power within each of us. This ability, when we open ourselves up to it, to be more aware and ergo radically present, leads us to overcome judgement and approach each passing moment with greater curiosity.

L: This is really the key; the key to unlocking this Hineini State of Mind, the power for each of us to approach one another with loving openness, nonjudgemental curiosity, and a willingness to see how we can be here, truly, for one another.

E: This is what we hope for each of us this coming year. Here, beside this lake and in this moment—

L: And even beyond– throughout these Holy Days and as we engage with community and one another throughout the year—

E: Let the blasts of the shofar, the beautiful and sometimes haunting melodies of this season, the readings of our sacred texts, our creative art, yoga, and journaling moments, let all of this be our keys to unlocking our super power of Hineini.

L: And may our Hineini State of Mind in and among our Tahoe Jewish Community guide us toward radical presence everyday.

E: Shanah Tovah U’Mitukah – a Sweet and Good New Year!

The Miracle of Each Other – Rosh Hashanah 5787

by Rabbi Evon J. Yakar 

Shanah Tovah!

He was deep in prayer, standing on his front porch as the rain fell.  It had started slow, but now it was pouring.  The news was urging everyone to evacuate.  He remained on his porch praying.  A neighbor came by in a canoe, “Hey!  Get in!”  He yelled back, “Thank you, but God will save me.”  As the deluge continued, waters rising, he was now on his second story porch.  A rescue team in a motorized boat came, “Hey!  Get in, the rain is getting heavier and the flood waters are only rising.”  “Thank you, but God will save me,” he replied again.  The flood forced him to his roof and he held a Bible while reciting Psalms.  A helicopter appeared through the clouds, and the Search and Rescue team, calling from a megaphone, “Grab the ladder, this is the last opportunity.”  He yelled back, “Thank you, God will save me!”

Well, that was his last chance.  As the man approached the pearly gates of heaven, a bit peeved, and with disappointment in his voice he lodged his complaint against God, “I’ve done good works, I supported the community, I prayed, read Psalms, why didn’t you save me?”  To which God replied, “I sent a canoe, a boat, and even a helicopter!” 

The drowning man is ridiculous, right?  Refuse the boats, the helicopter – crazy, right?  Who would be so steadfastly stubborn as to insist that salvation arrive in exactly the expected form, not open to possibility?  

Or would we?

As folks committed to community and peoplehood, individuals and families motivated to be here welcoming this New Year, some of deep traditional faith, and others holding faith in each other and connection, what does help look like?  What does it mean to accept it?  Ask for it?  What hinders us from embracing interdependence?

Maybe not while drowning, I hope, yet how often do we insist:  I’ve got this.  I can handle it.  I don’t want to be a burden.  I can figure this out myself.

I was reminded of this parable recently when reading Dr. Angela Duckworth’s article, “I Study Successful People.  They Have One Habit in Common.”  She opens with a story of her own:

I was once stranded with my 86-year-old mother in the Atlantic Ocean. We were on a snorkeling excursion off the coast of Miami, and the two of us were quickly swept behind our boat, my mother overtaken by the current. In her panic, she’d inhaled water into both lungs and lost consciousness. Attempting to tug her to safety, I thrashed and kicked with all my might, but the ocean swallowed my efforts whole. Lungs burning, legs heavy, I changed tactics. I used one hand to keep her head above water and waved the other wildly in the air, shouting for help as I did.

Ultimately, what saved my mother’s life that day, and mine, too, was not fighting the current on my own. It was calling for help. The rescuers who came to our aid knew more than I did about how to handle this kind of emergency. Together, they got my mom onto the boat deck, then to solid ground and finally into the hands of expert medical staff who could care for her properly.

It is often clear to us when others should ask for help.  We are much less skilled at recognizing when that someone is us.  Sure, the drowning man, to us safely on firm ground, is a ridiculous image as he refuses the boats, and the helicopter, its laughable.  Yet, Duckworth’s story identifies for us a crucial reality:  The drowning man in the parable is a fool, we are not.  We have legitimate motivations keeping us from asking for help.  We don’t want to burden others.  We do not know who to ask.  Pride.  Fear.  Shame. We equate our need for help, often, with weakness.  Why?

As Duckworth writes, “…Americans are encouraged to pursue rugged individualism over interdependency.”

Openness, willingness to seek and ask for help is crucial to achievement Duckworth points out.  The sharing of ideas, the ways in which we are enriched by the social connection – the interdependence is immeasurable and invaluable.  

In the parable, the boat is the vehicle of another person’s help.  For Duckworth and her mother, yes a boat, but the medical team and rescuers were their boat.  Today, as we welcome this New Year, we are leaning on our tradition and community as our boat, our help.  Sometimes Torah is the boat.  Take today and the next ten days as an example.  The liturgy alone reminds us that we are in this together, we are interconnected and interdependent.  Avinu Malkeinu – the suffix “Nu” – OUR – first person plural, Our Father, Our King.  Or the recognizable alphabet of woe as it is often described:  Ashamnu, bagadnu, gazalnu (we’ll save the rest for Yom Kippur), yet notice again the same suffix “Nu” – WE have sinned, WE have betrayed, WE have stolen….  Even our most intimate spiritual reckoning takes place in the grammar of “we.”

In Pirke Avot – the Ethics of our Fathers, Hillel teaches, “Do not separate yourself from the community.”  But don’t stop reading here, because in his next breath, “Do not be overly confident in yourself.”  Even more striking is the literal translation of that second affirmation:  Do not trust in yourself until the day of your death!  Do not withdraw from others in other words…and do not imagine yourself sufficient unto yourself.  

There is help because I cannot do something myself.  There is help because we can do some things better…together.  And, there is help because relationship itself changes who each of us is.  We have a need for one another not because we cannot do it ourselves, but rather because we are human.  

Take a lesson from our Talmud.  Rabbi Yohanan’s student Rabbi Hiyya bar Abba fell ill.  R. Yohanan asked him, “Do you desire to be ill and suffering?”  To which he responded, “Neither this suffering nor its reward do I welcome.”  Yohanan asked for his hand, stood him up and restored him to health.  When Rabbi Yohanan himself fell ill, Rabbi Hanina visited him, asking him the same question, “is your suffering dear to you?”  Yohanan replied, “I welcome neither the suffering nor its reward.”  Hanina took his hand, stood him up and restored him to health.  The Gemara, in its wisdom and insight, asks, “Why did Yohanan wait for Hanina, let Yohanan stand himself up.”  Answering its own question, the collective voice of the Gemara answers, “Ein chavush matir atzmo – a prisoner cannot generally free himself.”  

Talmud, our tradition, lays before us a crucial question for this season:  What are the prisons from which I cannot release myself?  What “boats” am I not noticing, aware enough to recognize?  A habit, a story I tell about myself, a resentment, a relationship I cannot see clearly, a mistake I keep rationalizing, grief I continue to carry quietly and privately?  It seems that Teshuvah is not a solitary project.

Our community is enhanced when we embrace others, whether members or visitors.  We do this, yes because we are small in number, yet we also know that everyone’s soul that joins in our living of Jewish community and Jewish life enriches the whole endeavor.  After all, this is what our congregations, and our community are built upon.  B Mitzvah students becoming teachers of Torah and visitors joining with us, often noticing an opportunity to pitch in, breathing more life into all we do.  The eitz chaim art in the North Tahoe Hebrew Congregation sanctuary, was made whole because everyone had an opportunity to contribute – more was possible than the artist working alone.  And the healing quilt in the Temple Bat Yam sanctuary, squares of creativity sewn together as one piece to wrap those in need of healing…these are the results of seeking help and input.  Each could have been accomplished by a single individual, but that would have missed the point.     

In the Talmud, we discover an illuminating way to know this kind of generativity.  In tractate Ta’anit, the sages are discussing the value of Torah study.  Rabbi Hama ben Rabbi Hanina asks, “What is the meaning in Proverbs, ‘Iron sharpens Iron’?  Answering his own question, “just as one sharpens his friend.”  The verse comes to tell us that just as with these iron implements, one sharpens the other when rubbed against one another, so too, when two study Torah, they sharpen one another in their understandings, in their knowledge, and in their insights..  

We find moments in life when we need a hand because we cannot stand, or walk, or do whatever it is on our own.  Yet, there are so many instances when I need you, when we need one another even, or especially, when we are standing perfectly well.  Each of us is limited, a mind, heart, and soul working alone reaches its limit.  Inviting support enables us to imagine additional perspectives and learn from each other.  And the ancient rabbis also ask why Torah is compared to fire.  They teach that a fire cannot be kindled with a single piece of wood; Torah does not endure when one studies alone.  Iron needs iron to sharpen and wood needs wood to burn.  Something happens between us, when we share ideas, energy, and passion.  And that begins with a request…an ask…being able to reach to one another.

Our need for others is not only in moments of need or crises and reaching towards each other takes practice and skill.  Wayne Baker, a researcher and professor at the University of Michigan, has spent years exploring and explaining social relationships.  Part of his work, together with Adam Grant an organizational psychologist at the Wharton School, developed what they call the Reciprocity Ring, which is when everyone in a group must make a meaningful request, and everyone helps meet the requests of others. The surprising discovery, according to Baker, was that getting people to help is not the hard part; getting people to ask is. The request becomes the “ticket of admission.” 

We can extrapolate and learn from this that perhaps asking for help is itself a gift we give others…our community.  Because my willingness to need you gives you permission to someday need me, or others.  If we were all only helpers, that’s not exactly community; the exchange of requests and support of ideas and the subsequent outcomes is.  The best news, though, about Baker’s work, is that asking and reciprocity are skills we can cultivate.  These High Holy Days are an opportunity to assess and yearn to continue nurturing not only the connections between us, but the skills to seek and offer help.  

As I often include when addressing wedding couples under their chuppah, their wedding canopy, from the American poet Edwin Markham, “There is a destiny which guides us, none goes his way alone.  What you put into the lives of others comes back into your own.”  

I recall a moment nearing the end of my rabbinical school studies, a true “aha” moment.  I was struggling for the words to write a thank you note to my thesis advisor, Dr. Jonathan Cohen.  We were meeting for a celebratory dinner, and I had a gift for him.  It was then, that I recalled the teaching from Pirke Avot, “עשה לך רב וקנה לך חבר – Discover for yourself a teacher and acquire for yourself a friend.”  As I wrote that thank you note, I described the ways I sought a teacher, a rabbi, and discovered a friend, another with whom we could sharpen our insights and ideas together, and beyond.  It was suddenly easy to write that thank you note.  Dr. Cohen put energy into being our teacher, gave us the tools and the practice to discover the depths of meaning layered within our sacred texts.  The relationship with Dr. Cohen, my classmates and my teachers, changed who each of us became, and continue to become.      

Relationships change who we become.  We need each other, our relationships, not merely for what we can accomplish together, but because being known, challenged, loved, accompanied, and needed by others shapes who each of us becomes.

Who are the people we need beside us to become the people we are praying to become in 5787?

The boat is no longer merely rescue; it becomes a colleague, challenger, liturgy, community, one another.

On this first day of this New Year, we are here to lean on the richness of our Jewish tradition and each other – our community, our people – as our boat, our help.  The powerful and ancient liturgy of these Days of Awe enables us to articulate something for which we do not always have the words.  

Sometimes we are the boat, too. Sometimes another person’s prayer for help is answered, at least in part, by us.

During these Days of Awe, we ask in our hearts, with our liturgy, in searching our deeds:

Help me change; Help me forgive; Help me find the courage; Help me find my way back; Help me become more generous; Help me become more fully the human I have the potential to become.  Perhaps God’s response is, “I sent you each other!”

May this New Year be one in which we recognize the boats we need to stop waving away, a year in which we better understand for whom we might be the boat, and may we know that each of our interactions, each of our moments living in relationship and community are an expression of our being human…they help us continue becoming.

Shanah Tovah U’Mitukah – a Year sweetened by each other!  

Rabbi Lauren’s Rosh Hashanah Sermon

Rosh HaShanah Sermon
Rosh HaShanah Day, 5787: NTHC
September 12, 2026

On Rosh HaShanah, we celebrate what it means to be a part of Creation. This is an exciting moment in our yearly cycle. We have been lucky enough to complete another year around the sun, and we are grateful. We have arrived at the birthday of the world, and we spend time envisioning our hopes and goals for the year to come. As a part of that celebration, we often revisit the Creation stories in our sacred texts.

The Torah opens not with one creation story, but with two. In Genesis 1:1–2:4a, creation unfolds in a majestic, miraculous sequence over six days. God speaks the universe into being, bringing order out of chaos, culminating in humanity—male and female together—created b’tzelem Elohim, in the divine image (Genesis 1:27). Immediately afterward, Genesis 2:4b–25 offers a very different account. Here, the focus narrows from the cosmos to a garden, from the rhythm of creation to the intimacy of relationship. The human being is formed from the dust of the earth, the adamah, and life is breathed into them. Companionship, moral choice, individual agency, and the care of Creation arise as central themes. Rather than presenting these narratives as contradictions to be resolved, many rabbis before us understand them as different perspectives, each revealing a different truth about what it means to be human. We are both part of the vast, sometimes chaotic, sometimes ordered universe, and also, we are deeply relational beings, called to cultivate and connect and stumble our way through the complexities of life.

Yet these are not the only ways our Bible tells the story of Creation.

Chapters 8 and 9 of the Book of Proverbs imagine Wisdom as a woman, calling out from mountaintops and crowded entrances to city gates. “I, Wisdom, live with Prudence,” she declares. “Mine are counsel and resourcefulness; I am understanding and courage is mine.” (Proverbs 8:12, 14)

And then Lady Wisdom tells us that she was there at Creation:

“I was there when the heavens were set into place;
When the horizon was fixed on the deep;
When the heavens above were made firm;
And the fountains of the deep gushed forth…” (Proverbs 8:27–28)

She witnessed the Creation that Genesis 1 and 2 describes. She knows the chaos and the order. She knows the waters and the heavens, the dust and the garden. But when Wisdom tells the story, she remembers something else:

“I was with God as a confidant,
A source of delight every day,
Rejoicing before the Divine at all times,
Rejoicing in God’s inhabited world,
Finding delight with mortals.” (Proverbs 8:30–31)

In her retelling of Creation, Wisdom could have remembered Power or Majesty. She could have remembered Omnipotence and Reverence. Instead, when she records her story, she remembers delight. She remembers rejoicing. She remembers joy.

The world has not changed. The narrator has.

Wisdom does not deny the chaos of Genesis 1. She does not erase the vulnerability or moral complexity of Genesis 2. She looks at the same Creation and notices another truth within it. She remembers that she was rejoicing there.

Which raises a much harder question.

Can we learn to do that too?

Because this is all beautiful in the abstract. But frankly, it has been quite the year at our house. A year in which birthdays—even this one, when I get to celebrate the whole world with our community—feels hard to reframe with joy. It is one thing for our Proverbial Lady Wisdom to stand at the beginning of Creation and rejoice. But what happens when something in our own world has been broken? Can Wisdom’s way of seeing survive suffering?

My teacher, Rabbi Larry Hoffman, once told me that most of us are like our ancestor Isaac. We are blessed to re-dig the wells that our parents dug, but we also hold the trauma that they handed us. During the Torah portion that Amy so beautifully read, we hear the word “love” for the first time in the Torah. Let me repeat that: the first time that the word love is used in the Torah is in this Torah portion, of all Torah portions. It describes Abraham’s deep and abiding love for Isaac. “Take your son, your favored one, Isaac, whom you love,” says Genesis 22:2.

And then we read the traumatic events of the Akedah, the binding and near-sacrifice of Isaac.

Professor Avivah Zornberg describes the transformed Isaac who emerges from this experience as the “Silent Patriarch.” Indeed, after his near-death, Isaac becomes an unusually quiet figure in our biblical narrative. Generations of commentators have wondered about the effects of that terrible day on the child who walked up the mountain with his father and miraculously, somehow came back down again.

Modern psychology gives us language for some of what can happen after trauma. Many people experience emotional numbing, withdrawal, detachment, or a reduced capacity to feel affection and pleasure. In clinical language, this reduced capacity for pleasure and joy is often called anhedonia. It can occur in PTSD as well as depression.

And so the descriptions we receive of Isaac after the Akedah become rare, precious glimpses into his inner life. Isaac is, after all, Yitzchak. The Hebrew word for Laughter. And, in many framings, this child named for laughter becomes the patriarch remembered for silence.

Which makes it all the more striking that laughter—or something very close to it—eventually appears in Isaac’s story again.

After the death of his mother and his own near-sacrifice, Isaac opens his heart to a new relationship and finds comfort in Rebecca (Genesis 24:67). Later, Isaac—Yitzchak, Laughter—is seen mitzachek, playing or laughing with Rebecca (Genesis 26:8). His family remains complicated, as families tend to be, but he blesses his sons. Eventually, Genesis tells us that Isaac dies “old and full of days” (Genesis 35:29).

The Torah never tells us exactly how Isaac got there.

We do not receive a biblical recovery plan. We are never told that Isaac “got over” the Akedah. Perhaps he never did. The scars of that mountain may have remained with him throughout his life. 

But trauma did not become the only narrator of Isaac’s story.

Somewhere alongside the silence, there was comfort and connection.

Somewhere alongside the memory of the knife, there was blessing.

And somewhere in the life of the patriarch named after Laughter, there was laughter again.

Perhaps this is what Lady Wisdom is trying to teach us. Choosing joy does not mean rewriting the facts of our lives. It does not mean declaring painful things good. It means refusing to allow suffering to become the only narrator of our story.

In his book, Your Heart Was Made for This, Oren Jay Sofer writes:

“We suffer deeply in our world. Experiences of profound isolation, news of hate crimes or police violence, the spread of war, failure to act on the climate crisis—these take a toll on our hearts. Sometimes, I read the news and weep. In the face of suffering, joy nourishes the heart so that we have the resilience to open to pain and anger, feeling them, rather than shutting down or turning away. Joy creates space so that we may respond to difficulty with skill. Joy strengthens our spirits so that we can sustain courageous action.”

Choosing joy as we narrate and frame the events of our lives enables us to endure.

Psychologists increasingly understand joy not simply as happiness or pleasure, but as a positive emotion that can change how we engage with the world. Psychologist Barbara Fredrickson’s “broaden-and-build” theory suggests that while emotions like fear narrow our attention toward immediate threats, positive emotions can do something different: they broaden our sense of possibility. Joy invites us to play, explore, create, connect, and engage. These moments may be fleeting, but what they help us build—relationships, creativity, knowledge, resilience, new ways of seeing—can endure long after the feeling itself passes.

Joy, then, does not require us to believe that everything is good. It does not demand that we deny grief or difficulty. Joy asks us to notice something additional, to see that even within a complicated life, we can allow ourselves to move toward goodness. And perhaps that word—notice—is where Lady Wisdom has been pointing us all along. 

This past Lag B’Omer, I wrote to our community about two categories of joy. The first is a kind of joy that arrives spontaneously, almost without effort—I called it wild joy. Like wildflowers, wild joy is found in the moments that pop up around us in the fields of our lives. A burst of laughter. A feeling of connection. The sudden recognition of beauty. It steals our attention and it surprises us. This kind of joy is real and necessary; it reminds us that life has its own generosity.

Wild joy cannot be scheduled or even necessarily anticipated. We cannot command the wildflowers to bloom precisely when we need them. But we can learn to observe, learn to notice them when we stumble upon their open blossoms.

There is also another kind of joy; it is quieter and more deliberate: it is what I like to call Cultivated Joy. This category of joy is the kind that requires us to tend the soil of our souls, to diligently plant seeds and, after careful tending, watch them grow. Slowly, sometimes almost invisibly, we harvest this kind of joy through deliberate choices. It is not always immediate, but it can be enduring. It is the fruit of a life being lived with intention.

The Garden of Life that we inhabit is wide and vast. There is room for suffering and grief. There is room for trauma and silence. We know these garden beds well. But there is also space, even in the smallest corners, to allow Lady Wisdom to plant her seeds of delight and joy, to allow her to tutor us in how to plant our own. In her book (that we just finished as a part of our Book Club!), The Amen Effect, Rabbi Sharon Brous offers us a practice from Chapter 5: Make room for joy. But building a new garden bed in our hearts takes some intention. And like any varied garden, there are quite a few seeds that we can choose to cultivate. 

The first is Long-Grown Joy.

It is a varietal of what Rabbi Evon refers to as “Type 2” Fun. But today, let’s think of it as Fruit Tree Joy.

In the Talmud, in Taanit 23b, Honi the Circle Maker encounters a man planting a carob tree. When Honi asks how long the tree will take to bear fruit, the man replies: seventy years. Honi asks whether he really expects to live long enough to enjoy it. The man explains that just as his ancestors planted for him, he plants for those who will come after him.

Now, Long-Grown or Fruit Tree Joy does not necessarily require us to wait seventy years.

Leviticus 19:23-25 describes the patience required of those who plant fruit trees of other varietals. We root, and we cultivate. We water, and we wait. We mark the passage of time. And eventually, after a few years, we enjoy the fruit.

There are joys in our lives that grow this way. Learning something difficult. Building a friendship. Raising a child. Maintaining a loving marriage. Developing a craft. Getting a degree. Cultivating community. Working toward a goal whose reward cannot possibly arrive tomorrow.

Long-Grown Joy asks us to know what we hope to plant and then to tend it with determination and attention over the passage of time. It teaches us that sometimes joy is not the reward waiting for us at the finish line. Sometimes joy is realizing that the tiny tree we have been watering for years has finally begun to bear fruit.

The second is Shared Joy.

I see Shared Joy in the Arba Minim, the Four Species we gather into the lulav and etrog and joyfully shake in our sukkah each year (and don’t forget to check the website for our fabulous Sukkot celebrations! Mark your calendars for Brisket and Brews!), or even in the quieter companionship of the Seven Species associated with the Land of Israel and the holiday of Shavuot.

The gardens of our lives are ecosystems, not collections of isolated plants.

They flourish because countless living things nourish one another beneath the surface. They blossom because pollinators carry tiny bits of golden dust from the heart of one flower to another. Life generates more life.

And, it is possible that joy can generate more joy.

A friend’s graduation or promotion. A cousin’s wedding. A sibling’s new baby. A colleague’s healing. A classmate’s extraordinary vacation. Sometimes we experience joy not because something wonderful has happened to us, but because we have opened our hearts wide enough to experience the joy of another person.

We often imagine emotional strength as radical independence. But communities can become places where joy circulates. Someone else’s song becomes our song. Someone else’s confidence steadies our own. A friend’s excitement reminds us that joy still exists even when we struggle to see it ourselves.

Shared Joy teaches us that we do not have to manufacture all of our joy alone. Sometimes we simply have to allow some of that golden dust to drop into the depth of our own hearts.

The third is Seasonal Joy.

Our Jewish calendar was built by people who understood harvests.

Barley ripens around Passover. Wheat follows around Shavuot. By the season of Sukkot, we celebrate the ingathering of the produce of field and orchard and vine. Different things become ready at different times.

We understand this instinctively in a garden. We would never stand beneath a fig tree in winter and accuse it of failure. We would never look across a field of barley and complain that it has neglected to give us grapes.

We know that different things ripen in different seasons.

Yet somehow, when we look at our own lives, we forget.

We become impatient because someone else seems to have reached their harvest before us. Or because something that once brought us tremendous joy no longer does. Or because the life we inhabit now does not look like the life we thought we would inhabit at this age or stage or place.

There are joys we discover young, joys we discover later, joys that return after years away, and joys we could not possibly have recognized until experience taught us how to see them. We experience them, we love them, and we can still learn how to let one season go and another season of joy bud for some future harvest. 

Seasonal Joy asks a different question from the one we so often ask ourselves. Not: Why don’t I have what they have? Not even: Why don’t I still have what I once had?

Instead: What is ripening now? What belongs to this season of my life?

We don’t regard the absence of one harvest as evidence that the whole garden has failed. We notice what is ready to be gathered. And what is fodder for a different season. 

Which brings us to our fourth kind of cultivated joy: Restorative Joy.

This is the joy grown from compost.

Every gardener knows that healthy soil contains the remains of what once lived, transformed over time into nourishment for new growth. Nothing about compost is particularly pleasant while it is being made. Yet without the decomposition of what has fallen, gardens struggle to flourish.

Somehow, life learns to grow from what has been lost. 

Perhaps this is the kind of joy we glimpse in Isaac. Here, though, we need to be very careful, because this is not a sentimental claim that everything happens for a reason, or that every tragedy eventually reveals a hidden blessing. There are wounds that remain wounds. There are losses that should never have occurred. Judaism has never asked us to deny grief or rush toward optimism. We mourn honestly. We lament fully. We tear our garments and sit in silence because love deserves that kind of truthfulness.

Compost does not resurrect what was lost.

The fallen leaf does not become the same leaf again.

Instead, what has been lost becomes part of the soil in which something new may someday grow.

Over the course of a lifetime, some of us are lucky enough to discover that sorrow can deepen rather than diminish our capacity for joy. Compassion can grow where suffering has been known. Gratitude can become more vivid after loss. Wisdom can emerge from surviving what once seemed impossible to endure.

Restorative Joy is not happiness despite grief. It is the astonishing possibility that grief and joy do not have to be enemies. Our hearts are big enough for both. Our capacity to love what is here can coexist with our longing for what is gone. That somewhere in soil enriched by all that has lived and died before, a perennial we had almost forgotten might push its way toward the sun.

None of these joys is better than another. Wild Joy teaches us to notice. Long-Grown Joy teaches us to tend. Shared Joy teaches us to connect. Seasonal Joy teaches us to love what is ripe. Restorative Joy teaches us to remain open to what might grow again.

And beneath all of them, we return to the same spiritual practice: attention.

A gardener cannot cultivate what she does not first observe.

She has to notice the condition of the soil. She has to know where sunlight falls and where shadows linger. She learns which plants need water and which need patience. She notices the volunteer flower that somehow appeared where she never planted one. She learns when to prune, when to harvest, when to compost, and sometimes when simply to stand still and marvel at what has grown.

Lady Wisdom does the same thing, after all.

She looks at Creation—all of it—and then, she purposefully lifts up delight.

Isaac’s story invites us to do the same. Not to erase the mountain and the binding, but to notice that this story is not the final scene. There is companionship. There is comfort. There is blessing. There is laughter.

And here we are, at Rosh HaShanah.

Another birthday of the world. Another telling of Creation. Another year in which we are invited to look back at the story we have lived and begin imagining the story we might tell in the year ahead.

We are not being asked to declare that everything about the past year was good. Some of it wasn’t.

And. We are not being asked to reframe every loss as blessing, every wound as wisdom, every disappointment as opportunity. Some things deserve simply to be mourned.

But this moment is asking us whether those things will be permitted to tell the whole story. Because when Lady Wisdom tells the story of Creation, she remembers joy. When Isaac’s story continues after the Akedah, the Torah still finds room for comfort and laughter. And when we look back across the garden and harvests of our own year, perhaps we can learn to notice what grew there too.

What surprised us with wild joy?

What finally bore fruit after years of patient tending?

Whose joy pollinated our own?

What ripened only in this particular season?

What new growth emerged, astonishingly, from soil shaped by what we had lost?

These questions do not change the facts of the year behind us. They change the breadth of the story we are able to tell about it.

Through our time here today, as our thoughts turn to our page in the Book of Life, we notice that the story of the coming year has not yet been written. It opens our hearts to the possibility of the New Year.

After all, this coming year’s garden has not yet been planted.

But Lady Wisdom is already here, standing at the edge of our garden, rejoicing in the inhabited, finding delight with Creation.

Shanah Tovah. 

Events